The Four Fanmade: Season 1

The Four
An asterisk indicates one of the original members of "The Four," who were Caroline Dean, Coby Carter, Hannah Hardacre, and Marissa Rein.

Key:
 * – Challenger against "The Four" won and secured a seat as a new member.
 * – Member of "The Four" did not perform.
 * – Member of "The Four" won the challenge and secured their seat.
 * – Member of "The Four" lost the challenge and was eliminated.
 * – Challenger to "The Four" lost their challenge and was eliminated.
 * – An eliminated artist who was chosen to return to the competition via #TheFourComeback earned a chance to challenge "The Four".
 * – Artist was chosen to return to the show, but lost their opportunity to challenge one of "The Four" when another comeback artist defeated them.
 * – Not in the competition.
 * – Final member of “The Four”.

Challenge Episodes
Key:
 * – Artist secured a spot and has remained in "The Four".
 * – Artist won their challenge, but was eventually eliminated from the competition.
 * – Artist was eliminated from the competition.
 * – Artist lost their challenge, and was originally eliminated, but received a second chance via #TheFourComeback.

Week 7
Eight eliminated contestants returned to the competition in an attempt to claim or re-claim a seat on "The Four".

Part 1: Head-To-Head Battles
The audience selected one from each pair to challenge one of the members of "The Four".

Part 2: Comeback Artist Challenge Performances
After winning their Head-to-Head battles, the four comeback artists each challenged a member of "The Four" for an opportunity to claim a seat.

Part 1: Head-to-Head Battles
In Part 1, the finalists each performed two songs. For the first song, each finalist performed in hopes of winning over the audience. After performing, the audience voted on their favorite performance, and the finalist with the most votes earned the power to choose who they wanted to battle against in the head-to-head challenge. For their second song, each selected pair went head-to-head. The audience voted for a winner from each pair to move on to the final battle.

Part 2: The Final Battle
For the final battle, the two finalists performed once more for the votes of the audience. The winner of this battle would be crowned the winner of The Four.